Rosyfinch Ramblings
Comments are not moderated here - please visit NEW SITE FOR ROSYFINCH.COM
Categories:

Archives:
Meta:
November 2017
M T W T F S S
« Nov    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  
07/03/12
Review: How to Be a Better Birder
Filed under: General, Birding & Outdoors, Book Reviews
Posted by: Ken @ 1:24 pm

Review: How to Be a Better Birder
by Derek Lovitch
Princeton University Press
208 pages, 53 color illustrations, 10 maps  



Look inside on Amazon.com

It’s easy to judge a book by its title. This one is “How to Be a Better Birder.” Not how to “Become,” but how to “Be.” Me, I’m always “becoming,” but I must admit that I have not yet arrived. I’d be too embarrassed to tell you my worst stories, but here are a couple that are not near as bad as those.

Before leading a Saturday morning bird walk at Rio Grande Nature Center in Albuquerque, I scouted out the area adjacent to the starting point. In a Cottonwood conveniently situated near the entrance trail I found a Greater Roadrunner moving about high in the branches, probably searching for a meal of hummingbird eggs or Mourning Dove nestlings. About 15 minutes later, as I led my charges along the path, I casually looked up at a brown blob moving between the green leaves and began to expound on the interesting behavior of the roadrunner. Well, one of the young participants pointed out that I was looking at a squirrel!

The first chapter of Lovitch’s book is subtitled “The ‘Whole Bird and More’ Approach.” Ho hum– Oh yes, I’ve heard this so many times, but what’s that about “More?” Maybe my approach requires fine tuning.

While walking a trail in the wetlands near my new home in south Florida, I spotted a bird soaring quite high in the sky. Easy call. Flying Bird → Hawk → Buteo → red tail → ? Duh, stop here, take its picture and move on to the next bird.

Short-tailed Hawk Light Morph 20100108

If I had applied some of the “More” that is packed into this compact handbook I would have noted that, in addition to its somewhat smaller size, this hawk presented a more graceful silhouette, and shorter pointed wings with comma-shaped light areas just inside their black tips. It wheeled in tighter circles, lacked dark patagial marks and had no belly band. The red in its tail was caused by diffusion of sunlight from above, not the red pigment of a Red-tailed Hawk. It was the first light morph Short-tailed Hawk I had ever seen, and I did not identify it until I looked at my photos on the computer screen back home.
 
I found the first chapter so interesting that I just had to try out some of Lovitch’s advice. Especially interested in the sparrow clan, the author provides two facing pages that illustrate the profiles of each genus. Everybody knows that Song Sparrows (Melospiza) are shaped differently than Chipping Sparrows (Spizella) and Swamp Sparrows (Passerculus). Yet we are encouraged to go beyond “general shape and size” and analyze the subtleties of size and shape of head, bill, tail, chest and belly. Don’t be fooled by some markings, such as chest spots. Lovitch provides an interesting artistic interpretation of plumage details:

“A Song Sparrow is an oil painting… Lincoln’s… is akin to a pen-and-ink drawing, while the washed-out, blurry streaking and more subtle contrasts of the Swamp Sparrow are like a watercolor.”   

I set out into the field and found my Oil Painting…

Song Sparrow 20100314

…a Pen-and-ink Drawing…

Lincolns Sparrow 5-20101029

…and a Washed-out Watercolor.

 Swamp Sparrow 2-20110512

Lovitch cautions us not to rely on the infamous breast-spot to identify a bird as a Song Sparrow. All three of the above sport one, as does this Vesper Sparrow…

Vesper Sparrow 2-20110614

…and of course, the Savannah Sparrow.

Savannah Sparrow 20120506

I have misidentified all of the above sparrows in the past, and probably will continue to do so, but perhaps with less frequency. It was time to move on to the next chapter, “Birding by Habitat.”

Sure, we all know not to look for Sage Sparrows in a swamp, but Lovitch goes beyond the basics and  challenges us to learn more about vegetation types and micro-habitats. Know the plants and you will know which birds are looking for food and shelter there. My aging brain simply does not retain all the names of the various grasses, shrubs and trees (and this is also true for butterflies, dragonflies and other insects, not to mention the last ten people who were introduced to me at a party), but it is nice renewing my acquaintance with the same ones over and over again!

The book addresses the importance of geography in the movement of migrating birds and predicting where they may concentrate in various seasons and weather conditions. Lovitch explains the importance of weather-related “overshoots.” On a macro scale, migrants may end up far out of their normal range because of such factors as faulty navigation, hurricanes or weather systems. Locally, overshoots occur most often over water, when migrating land birds must reverse course to seek the safety of the shoreline. 

I found the chapter on “Birding by Night” to be captivating, as I read it when spring migration was at a peak. This is not only about listening to chirps in the night and watching the moon. It contains detailed instructions for constructing your own personal radar display to capture and interpret images from the previous night.

“Birding With a Purpose” emphasizes the importance of contributing to the greater fund of birding knowledge, whether through individual record-keeping and reporting on e-Bird and RBAs, participating in organized counts, census and banding activities, or even seeking volunteer opportunities or employment in scientific research endeavors. As is the case in earlier chapters, the book provides a wealth of pertinent references.

After a discussion of vagrants, Lovitch presents  “A New Jersey Case Study,” which details the successes and failures of his birding trip to Cape May. He applies some of the concepts set out in his book, particularly relating to the ability to predict where the birds might show up under sometimes challenging weather conditions. 

Finally, he extolls the benefits and joys of patch birding, or more properly, “Patch Listing,” strengthening my resolve to be more of a lister. It is so easy to neglect the value of properly recording the arrival, ebb and flow of species in a familiar spot. I resolve to improve in this aspect of my “Becoming” a better birder, even though I may never “Be” one. 

Disclaimer: Princeton University Press supplied me with a review copy of this book.

Shared on Birding is Fun, July 3, 2012

12 Responses to “Review: How to Be a Better Birder”

  1. Boom & Gary Says:
    What a great post!! I’m going to have to look at that book. Boom & Gary of the Vermilon River, Canada.
  2. Mick Says:
    Great photos - as usual! - and it sounds like an interesting book.
  3. Adam Jones Says:
    Some really fantastic birds there. I love the Savannah Sparrow.
  4. Carole M. Says:
    I’m really loving your photograph of the song-sparrow! Isn’t that the greatest, ‘discovering’ when you open up your pics on the computer?!
  5. Eileen Says:
    Great collection of Sparrows, Ken! They are one of the hardest species for me to id. Your photos are awesome as usual. Have a happy 4th of July!
  6. fjällripan Says:
    Really great photos!! /Susanne
  7. I'd Rather B Birdin' Says:
    Great photos, I especially liked the very last one, but y’know Sparrows, there are so many species, it IS difficult to identify them. RUDDY DUCK
  8. Trisha Says:
    Fantastic review, Ken! Your photos are amazing….I learned so much. No longer can I id sparrows by chest spots….lol But I don’t feel too bad if you did the same…as you are the best birder I know Ken.
  9. Roan Says:
    I loved each shot, but especially like that last sparrow. We have tons of sparrows, but haven’t been lucky enough to see that one. Rubbish by Roan
  10. Pat Says:
    Love your stories. Great photos of the often misidentified sparrows.
  11. Mary Howell Cromer Says:
    Very nice and those beautiful Sparrows…I have the worst time with ID of these guys~
  12. ken schneider Says:
    Thank you all, for your encouraging comments. I especially like photographing sparrows, not only for the challenge, but to enjoy their subtle beauty.

Leave a Reply